stop making CSMs negotiate

You’re asking your CSMs to do two things that are fundamentally at odds.

You want them to be a trusted advisor.

Then you want them to be a bill collector.

Most Customer Success organizations still treat the renewal as a relationship milestone when it’s actually a commercial transaction. By forcing a CSM to own the contract negotiation, you compromise their ability to consult on value.

The customer stops seeing them as a partner and starts seeing them as a salesperson.

There’s also a skill gap that we rarely acknowledge.

CSMs are typically product and service experts. They are brilliant at ascribing value and driving adoption. But they’re rarely trained negotiators. They don’t want to hammer out payment terms or price increases.

When they’re forced to do that, the results are almost always arbitrary and inconsistent.

The most efficient companies have realized that specialization is the only way to scale. They separate the value journey from the commercial renewal.

The CSM owns the outcomes. The Renewal Manager owns the contract.

This allows the renewal to become a structured program rather than a series of custom negotiations. It turns the commercial side of the business into a repeatable engine.

In the current market, efficiency is the only game that matters.

Forcing your highest-paid relationship experts to struggle with order forms and contract redlines is a massive waste of capital. It keeps them from doing the work that actually prevents churn in the first place.

Take a look at your team's calendar this month.

How much time are they spending on contract paperwork versus customer strategy sessions? If they’re spending more time on the logistics of the renewal than the logic of the partnership, you have a structural problem.

It’s time to let your advisors advise, and your negotiators negotiate.

🤘