the effortless experience

"Delight your customers."

It's the mantra that's dominated customer success for years. We've been taught that to retain customers, we need to wow them with exceptional experiences, personalized service, and moments that exceed expectations.

But what if the conventional wisdom is wrong?

Matt Dixon's groundbreaking research in "The Effortless Experience" shows that the path to customer loyalty isn't paved with delight — it's built on reducing effort.

After analyzing thousands of customer interactions, Dixon and his team discovered something counterintuitive: going above and beyond rarely drives loyalty. But making things easy consistently does.

Let's dive into why effort — not delight — is the currency that matters most in customer retention...

When Dixon's team at CEB (now Gartner) investigated what drives customer disloyalty, they found something striking: 96% of customers who experienced high-effort interactions became disloyal, compared to only 9% of those who had low-effort experiences.

Think about your own experiences as a customer. What really makes you want to leave...?

Is it the lack of wow moments? Or is it the frustration of:

• Having to contact a company multiple times for the same issue

• Being forced to repeat information

• Experiencing channel switching (starting online, then being forced to call)

• Encountering policies that create extra work

• Having to figure things out yourself when help should be available

The data is clear: customers aren't leaving because you didn't delight them. They're leaving because you made their lives difficult.

Remember our discussion of the Dutcher Principle (the 98/2 rule) a few newsletters back? Here's where it applies again:

98% of companies invest in flashy delight programs that drive only 2% of loyalty, while the 98% of loyalty driven by reduced effort gets only 2% of companies' attention.

This explains why many "customer-centric" initiatives fail to move retention metrics. Companies focus on the wrong things because delight is more interesting to discuss in board meetings than reducing friction.

When we talk about customer effort, it's easy to think solely about UI/UX and product design. Those matter, but effort spans the entire customer experience:

1. Cognitive Effort

How much mental energy does your customer need to expend to:

• Understand how to use your product

• Know who to contact with specific issues

• Remember your processes and policies

• Learn your company's terminology and jargon

2. Time Effort

How much of your customer's time do you consume with:

• Long or complex onboarding

• Multiple touchpoints to resolve issues

• Meetings that could be emails (or automated entirely)

• Manual processes that could be automated

3. Emotional Effort

How much stress do you create through:

• Uncertainty about outcomes

• Anxiety over whether things are working properly

• Frustration from arbitrary policies or processes

• The feeling that customers need to "stay on top of" your team

According to Dixon, emotional effort isn't just a factor – it's the biggest driver of churn. When customers constantly feel they need to check your work, follow up, or worry about whether things are on track, they're burning emotional calories they'd rather spend elsewhere.

This ties in to what we discussed in our Cost to Retain newsletter. The more effort your customer has to exert, the more resources you need to deploy to keep them.

High-effort customer experiences create a perfect storm:

• Customers become frustrated and consider leaving

• Support and success teams spend more time addressing concerns

• Engineering resources get diverted to urgent fixes

• Executive time gets consumed with escalations

• Renewals require more negotiation and concessions

All of this drives up your Cost to Retain, eating into profitability and creating a drag on growth.

So what can you do to make your customer experience lower effort? Here are four strategies derived from Dixon's work that I've seen drive dramatic improvements in retention:

1. Address the Next Issue Preemptively

Dixon calls this "next-issue avoidance." When resolving a customer issue, don't just fix the immediate problem — anticipate and address the potential follow-up questions or concerns.

For example, if a customer reports an integration issue, don't just fix it. Also, provide information about how to verify that the fix is working, what might have caused it, and how to prevent it in the future.

2. Engineer Better Customer Language

Listen to how customers describe their problems, then adopt their language throughout your company.

A financial software company I advised discovered their customers rarely used the technical term "reconciliation error" that appeared in their help docs. Instead, customers searched for "numbers don't match." Changing the language reduced support tickets by 23%.

3. Create Contextual Self-Service

Self-service shouldn't mean "figure it out yourself." It should mean, "Here's exactly what you need, when and where you need it."

Contextual help that appears based on what the customer is doing — not generic FAQs they need to search through — slashes effort.

4. Enable Front-Line Judgment

Nothing increases customer effort more than rigid policies and disempowered support teams.

The companies with the lowest customer effort scores give their front-line teams clear decision-making frameworks rather than rigid scripts. They're empowered to solve problems, not just document them.

If you're serious about reducing customer effort, measure it. Dixon's research led to the development of the Customer Effort Score (CES), a simple metric that asks customers to rate their agreement with the statement: "The company made it easy for me to resolve my issue."

Companies that score well on CES consistently outperform on retention metrics. In fact, a study by Gartner found that CES is 1.8x more predictive of customer loyalty than CSAT and 2x more predictive than NPS.

Consider adding CES to your metrics dashboard, particularly for key customer touchpoints like onboarding, support interactions, and product changes.

The reality of reducing customer effort is that it's rarely exciting work. It's about fixing broken processes, streamlining communications, and removing unnecessary steps — not launching flashy new programs.

It's the customer success equivalent of paying down technical debt: unglamorous but critical.

As you think about your customer strategy for the rest of the year, consider shifting some of your "delight" budget toward effort reduction. You might find that the most powerful loyalty driver isn't doing more for your customers — it's asking less of them.

After all, in a world where everyone is busy and attention is scarce, the most valuable thing you can offer customers isn't another wow moment. It's giving them time back in their day.

🤘

We’re grateful you read each week. When you’re ready for more, there are a couple of ways we can help:

» Cover Your SaaS is a financial literacy course for go-to-market leaders. Grab your copy here.

» Promote your product and services to over 4,000+ senior SaaS Sales, Marketing, and Customer Success pros by sponsoring our twice-weekly newsletter and podcast.

Was this email forwarded to you? Sign up at ChiefCustomerOfficer.io.